A rising tide of type 2 diabetes in younger people: what can primary care do?

An increasing incidence of early onset type 2 diabetes in New Zealand is putting more people at risk of early mortality and complications such as cardiovascular disease at an age when other people in the community are at their prime. General practitioners, nurses, pharmacists and other primary health care professionals should consider how they can use their role to identify people at high risk and support them to create a different future.

0 comments
save
share
feedback
Log in

Key practice points:

  • The incidence of type 2 diabetes in younger adults and adolescents in New Zealand is increasing; people of Māori, Pacific and South-Asian ethnicities are particularly at risk
  • People with early onset type 2 diabetes have increased morbidity and mortality compared to those with a later onset or to those of similar age with type 1 diabetes
  • Preventing, or delaying, onset of type 2 diabetes is paramount to reducing the burden of diabetes complications; this may be possible with careful management
  • Test HbA1c levels in patients at high risk, regardless of their age, so that patients can be supported to make lifestyle changes before they develop diabetes
  • The management of type 2 diabetes in younger people is essentially the same as for older people but treatments need to be more assertive, e.g. pharmacological treatment escalated sooner
  • A high degree of patient engagement is crucial to maximise the benefits of lifestyle changes and ensure patients take their medicines as prescribed

This article focuses on the prevalence and management of diabetes in younger people. For information on type 2 diabetes in general, see: “Managing patients with type 2 diabetes: from lifestyle to insulin” www.bpac.org.nz/bpj/2015/december/diabetes.aspx

New Zealand has a diabetes problem, fuelled in part by one of the highest rates of obesity in the world.1 Approximately 6% of the total population has diabetes. The prevalence of diabetes is highest in older age groups, reaching approximately 15–20% in people aged over 65 years; however, prevalence is increasing in younger people in New Zealand.2 Data from the Ministry of Health’s Virtual Diabetes Register show the prevalence of diabetes in people aged 30–39 years has almost doubled over the last 12 years (Figure 1). Increases in diagnoses in children aged under 15 years have also been observed, although absolute numbers are still small.3

People of Māori, Pacific and South-Asian ethnicity, and people who are socioeconomically disadvantaged, bear a disproportionate burden of obesity and type 2 diabetes. The prevalence of diabetes is two to three and a half times higher in adults aged 25–39 years of Māori and Pacific ethnicity compared to those of European ethnicity (Figure 2). N.B. Increasing rates of type 2 diabetes may partially reflect greater awareness and testing over recent years.


Figure 1: Changes in the prevalence of diabetes from 2005-2017 in adults aged 25-39 years in New Zealand. Source: Virtual Diabetes Register and Statistics New Zealand

Figure 2: The prevalence of diabetes in adults aged 25–39 years by ethnicity, calculated from entries in the Virtual Diabetes Register compared to the population of the same age and ethnicity at the 2006 and 2013 censuses. Source: Virtual Diabetes Register and Statistics New Zealand

Many young people are at high risk of developing type 2 diabetes

People with HbA1c levels of 41–49 mmol/mol are classified as having “pre-diabetes”, which is associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease and progression to type 2 diabetes. Data from the most recent national nutrition survey identified that 16% of the population aged under 45 years had pre-diabetes.4 It is estimated that in the Auckland region, over 40% of people of Māori, Pacific or Indian ethnicity aged 35–39 years have pre-diabetes.2

The same factors which increase risk of type 2 diabetes in older adults influence risk in younger people, however, people who develop type 2 diabetes earlier tend to have a greater severity or number of risk factors. For example, the more members of a person’s extended family affected by type 2 diabetes, the higher their risk and the earlier the age of onset.5 Excess body weight is particularly prevalent in people who develop type 2 diabetes earlier in life: among people aged under 40 years with type 2 diabetes registered at the Auckland Diabetes Centre in 2015, the median BMI was 38 kg/m2.6 However, weight alone is not an absolute predictor of risk (see: “Is early onset type 2 diabetes in lean people different?”).

Early onset results in worse health outcomes

Younger people diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, e.g. before the age of 40 years, have a higher risk of early mortality, cardiovascular disease, chronic kidney disease and retinopathy than older adults diagnosed with type 2 diabetes or people with type 1 diabetes at a similar age.7-9 This is largely because people diagnosed younger have diabetes for longer and are therefore exposed to more risk, but also because glycaemic control tends to be worse and younger people are more likely to have sporadic contact with healthcare services.6,7

Negative outcomes for people diagnosed with type 2 diabetes earlier in life include:

Increased mortality: People diagnosed under the age of 40 years have a rate of mortality three to six times higher than those without diabetes. In contrast, people diagnosed over the age of 50 have at most a two-fold increase in mortality.9

Increased rates of cardiovascular disease: Data from Australia show that a ten year earlier onset of type 2 diabetes is associated with 1.6 times the risk of dying from cardiovascular disease.10

High rates of complications: In 2,000 children and young adults diagnosed with diabetes in the United States, the prevalence of kidney disease was 20% in those with type 2 diabetes compared to 6% in those with type 1 diabetes, and the rates of retinopathy and peripheral neuropathy were doubled.8

HbA1c should be tested in people at high risk of type 2 diabetes of any age. The benefit of this approach is to identify patients early, to reduce their risk of developing type 2 diabetes, and their risk of renal and cardiovascular complications. Diagnoses of type 2 diabetes are being made in young adults in New Zealand who already have very high HbA1c levels and albuminuria.6 Cardiovascular risk begins to increase at an HbA1c level of approximately 40 mmol/mol.12, 13 As type 2 diabetes is not necessarily associated with any symptoms, patients may not even recognise that they are at risk.

Identifying people at elevated risk

Ministry of Health guidelines recommend HbA1c testing in people with any of the following risk factors:2

  • A BMI of ≥ 27 kg/m2 for people of Māori, Pacific or South Asian ethnicities, or ≥ 30 kg/m2 for people of other ethnicities*
  • A first-degree relative who developed type 2 diabetes at an early age, e.g. < 40 years
  • Long-term use of oral corticosteroids
  • Females with a past personal history of gestational diabetes
  • Females with polycystic ovary syndrome
  • Severe mental illness, particularly those on long-term antipsychotic treatment
  • Known ischaemic heart, cerebrovascular or peripheral vascular disease

* A lower BMI threshold is recommended for people of Māori, Pacific or South Asian ethnicities due to the higher risk people of these ethnicities have of developing type 2 diabetes.2 South Asian ethnicities include Indian, Fijian Indian, Sri Lankan, Afghani, Bangladeshi, Nepalese, Pakistani and Tibetan.

A specific opportunity to incorporate HbA1c testing into routine practice is the cardiovascular risk assessment; the age at which to start assessments is now recommended as:14

  • Age 45 years for males and 55 years for females with no known risk factors
  • Age 30 years for males and 40 years for females of Māori, Pacific or South-Asian ethnicity
  • Age 35 years for males and 45 years for females with known cardiovascular risk factors or at high risk of developing diabetes

Further information on family and personal risk factors is available at: www.health.govt.nz/publication/cardiovascular-disease-risk-assessment-and-management-primary-care

Consider the possibility of type 1 diabetes or a monogenic form of diabetes in younger adults with elevated HbA1c without obesity, family history or other typical features such as hypertension, dyslipidaemia or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (see: “Excluding other forms of diabetes in people with early onset changes in glycaemia”).

One of the most important points to convey to people who have type 2 diabetes or pre-diabetes is that the course is modifiable. Changes to their lifestyle may be difficult at first, but they can substantially improve their future health. The patient will have to take the lead role in making those changes, but with support from their primary care team. Setting small, incremental goals can be helpful if patients are feeling overwhelmed by the extent of changes recommended (see: “Engaging people to make changes”).19

Weight loss has the potential to induce remission of type 2 diabetes in people who are overweight or obese, i.e. to achieve an HbA1c < 50 mmol/mol without the use of medicines,20 and should be regarded as a core focus of treatment.

Lifestyle change in people with pre-diabetes reduces their chance of developing diabetes by approximately 50–60% over three years and 27% over 15 years.12, 21 This includes aiming for a 7% weight loss, 2.5 hours per week of moderate intensity physical activity and following healthy diet recommendations.

Referral for bariatric surgery may be appropriate for some people who are obese to assist with weight loss (see: “Bariatric surgery to treat or prevent type 2 diabetes”).

Dietary advice

Dietary advice for people with type 2 diabetes or pre-diabetes is the same as advice for a healthy, balanced diet that is applicable to the rest of the population; emphasise to patients that an appropriate diet is more than just avoiding sugar.18 Various dietary approaches such as the Mediterranean diet, Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) and the 5+2 diet (intermittent fasting) have been studied in clinical trials, however, no one diet has been found to be superior for people with type 2 diabetes.18, 19 Likewise, there is no ideal percentage of energy intake from carbohydrates, protein or fat for all people with type 2 diabetes.18 The most successful diet is one that the person is able to maintain long-term and incorporate into their lifestyle and budget.

When discussing dietary options with patients, consider:19

  • Their knowledge about nutrition and whether they require more information and support about any particular aspects
  • What has or has not worked for them previously
  • Whether the changes being discussed are realistic, sustainable in the long-term and affordable
  • How to incorporate foods or food-related events important to their culture, religion or lifestyle

Referral to a dietitian can provide additional assistance for people regarding their dietary choices, such as education on the macronutrient content of foods, interpreting product labels, and help with meal planning and selecting healthy options at the supermarket. A dietitian can also assist if someone wishes to pursue more intensive dietary changes such as a very low calorie diet and the temporary use of meal replacement formulas. Some PHOs or DHBs offer a Diabetes Education and Self Management for Ongoing and Newly diagnosed Diabetes (DESMOND) course that people with type 2 diabetes or caregivers can attend; other similar courses are available in some areas.

Free copies of handouts for patients including healthy eating and activity advice are available from: www.healthed.govt.nz/resource/healthy-eating-active-living

Tools such as the Diabetes New Zealand “Take Control” app can provide people with information and recipe ideas on their phone: www.diabetes.org.nz/take-control-toolkit/

Further information on specific dietary approaches such as the Mediterranean, DASH or low calorie diet is available from the Ministry of Health: www.health.govt.nz/publication/clinical-guidelines-weight-management-new-zealand-adults

Activity advice

Key aspects:

  • Aim for at least 30 minutes of moderate intensity exercise, such as a brisk walk, on most days. This should be increased to 60 minutes per day where possible.
  • Include activities which can strengthen muscles on at least two days per week
  • Break up sitting time or prolonged periods of inactivity by standing up, stretching and walking around for a few minutes
  • Think creatively about exercise - choose activities that are enjoyable, sustainable and affordable

A Green Prescription can help people who may require extra motivation. A local Green Prescription provider can offer support via telephone, face to face or group sessions. The Green Prescription Active Families programme can assist if families have school-aged children that could benefit from support.

For further information on how to refer patients for a Green Prescription, see: www.health.govt.nz/system/files/documents/pages/greenprescriptionprocess-forprimaryhealthcare.pdf

Bariatric surgery to treat or prevent type 2 diabetes

Consider referral for bariatric surgery for patients who have a BMI between 35–55 kg/m2.19 A team within each DHB determines who is likely to gain the most benefit from surgery, taking into consideration factors such as the person’s social support and other health concerns that may affect suitability for surgery, e.g. smoking status and substance misuse.19

Bariatric surgery can induce remission of type 2 diabetes

In people who have type 2 diabetes, bariatric surgery can induce remission, as well as reduce the risk of diabetes complications, cardiovascular disease and some cancers.19 Rates of remission vary but on average across various studies 64% of people who underwent bariatric surgery had remission of type 2 diabetes, compared to approximately 16% managed with lifestyle and pharmacological treatment.22 People who are older, with a longer duration of diabetes and who require more intensive pharmacological treatment to manage HbA1c levels are less likely to achieve remission following surgery,23 therefore bariatric surgery in younger people may be more beneficial.

Surgery in people at high risk of type 2 diabetes can reduce their likelihood of developing it. A study in France found that 1.4% of people at high risk of type 2 diabetes who had bariatric surgery initiated diabetes medicines over the next six years, compared to 12% of those who did not have surgery.24

Māori and Pacific peoples may require more support to ensure they get the surgery they need

People accepted for bariatric surgery will need to commit to both pre-surgical and follow-up assessments. In New Zealand, more publicly funded bariatric surgeries are conducted for European people (3 per 1000 morbidly obese people) than for Māori (1.4 per 1000) or Pacific peoples (0.7 per 1000).25 The lower rates of surgery for people of Māori and Pacific ethnicity are likely due to higher rates of withdrawing after being accepted for surgery.26 Males also have higher rates of withdrawal than females.26 Impediments such as being able to balance the pre- and post-operative demands of surgery with work commitments, or not being able to achieve sufficient pre-operative weight loss, may make undergoing surgery more difficult for some of the people who stand to benefit the most. Discussing potential barriers with patients can help them to prepare and plan ahead for some of the difficulties they may face if they are accepted for surgery. Regular follow-up contact is also likely to be helpful once a patient has been accepted for surgery.

The approach to pharmacological management of patients with early onset type 2 diabetes is essentially the same as for older patients with type 2 diabetes, i.e. metformin first-line, followed by other oral hypoglycaemic medicines and insulin, as appropriate. However, faster escalation of treatments may be required and lower targets for glycaemic control are justified.27 Patients with early onset type 2 diabetes can have a more rapid increase in HbA1c levels, despite treatment, and are likely to require more frequent dose increases, use of multiple oral medicines or earlier addition of insulin than older patients with type 2 diabetes.5 Effective communication and engagement with patients in regards to the importance of adhering to their prescribed medicines is of particular importance in this age group.

Despite being young, patients may already have complications and should have their retinal, foot, renal and cardiovascular health fully assessed and managed at diagnosis. Also consider associated co-morbidities, such as sleep apnoea or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.

For further information on prescribing glucose-lowering medicines for patients with type 2 diabetes, see: www.bpac.org.nz/bpj/2015/december/diabetes.aspx

Metformin for patients with “pre-diabetes”

Metformin can be prescribed (unapproved indication) to reduce the risk of developing type 2 diabetes in patients at high risk (e.g. HbA1c of 46–49 mmol/mol), but should be considered an adjunct treatment in addition to changes in diet and activity levels.12 Metformin reduces the risk of developing type 2 diabetes by approximately one-third after three years, and approximately 20% after ten years, compared to a placebo medicine in patients at high risk.28

Managing cardiovascular and renal risk

Cardiovascular and renal diseases are the main causes of early mortality in people with type 2 diabetes, and preventing the onset or progression of these conditions in young people should be a focus of management.18 Lifestyle changes can improve markers of cardiovascular risk, such as blood pressure and lipid levels, however, pharmacological treatment should be initiated if lifestyle changes result in insufficient improvements, or if the patient’s risk is high.

For further information on managing cardiovascular and renal risk in patients with type 2 diabetes, see: www.health.govt.nz/publication/cardiovascular-disease-risk-assessment-and-management-primary-care

An online calculator for determining the risk of cardiovascular and renal disease in patients with type 2 diabetes is available at: www.nzssd.org.nz/cvd_renal/

When to seek further advice

Consider discussing patients with a diabetes specialist if appropriate management and adherence to treatment is ineffective in controlling progression of disease, e.g. HbA1c > 75 mmol/mol, declining renal function, significant albuminuria or other uncontrolled diabetes or cardiovascular complications.

Identify what motivates people

People can have very different reactions to a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, or being told they are at high risk. For some, it may be the first time they have had, or faced the prospect of, a serious medical condition and the potential consequences may be sufficient to motivate them to make changes. Others may be ambivalent, for example, a person who has a number of family members with type 2 diabetes may believe that getting diabetes themselves is inevitable, and there is not much that can be done. Motivational strategies should be individualised, but a key message for all people is that it is never too late to “step back from the edge” and their course of type 2 diabetes is not pre-determined.

A strategy that may resonate particularly for younger people is to ask them to think of their future plans and wishes; for example, having children and watching them grow up or plans for their career. Focusing on a positive message that those plans are still possible, may help patients to be motivated to make changes, by taking the emphasis away from the shock of a diagnosis and possible future complications, and changing it to what they can do keep those plans on track.

Avoiding stigma and blame

Discussing lifestyle changes can be challenging, as the advice required often carries an unspoken implication that the person has brought the disease on themselves. Even if the intention is good and the language appropriate, what people may believe they are being told is “you’re fat and lazy”.

The playing field is not level: The risk of type 2 diabetes and obesity is influenced by factors which are out of a person’s control, such as genetics, exposures in utero or early childhood, or factors in the environment.5 Conveying this may help alleviate some of the stigma and embarrassment associated with obesity and type 2 diabetes, and help people to change the focus from feeling personally responsible for their condition to what they can do to manage the risk that they have been born with or acquired.

Consider how weighing someone makes them feel: Some people may find being weighed during an appointment embarrassing or humiliating, and put them off returning for follow-up visits. Consider whether measuring their weight and tracking changes will hinder more than help. In some cases, e.g. if someone is visibly obese, measuring their weight will not alter management. However, other people may find that tracking their weight is a useful measure of progress and it provides positive reinforcement when they are meeting their goals.

Subtleties in language may imply blame: Consider nuances in language that can carry negative connotations. Advice on language which can help avoid blame when discussing type 2 diabetes is provided in Table 1.

A burden shared is a burden lightened: Helping people understand that others have difficulties making lifestyle changes can prevent them from feeling like their difficulties are a personal failing, and enable them to open up and share what they are finding challenging about making changes. Inclusive phrases which share your own or other people’s experiences can help, e.g. “Sometimes I don’t feel like exercising, but I just get started anyway and find I’m okay once I start”, or “other people I see with diabetes tell me what helps is…”. Involving others in the family can help people share the challenges of lifestyle change and provide them with additional support at home.

Options for follow-up support

Regular follow-up is essential for maintaining engagement with lifestyle changes, discussing progress and finding solutions to barriers that people may encounter. Develop an agreed plan that can be used to track progress. A useful strategy is to encourage patients to make one change at a time to transition to a healthier lifestyle with subsequent goals added at follow-up appointments, and helping people to focus on the changes that will bring the greatest benefit, such as weight loss or smoking cessation.

A team-based approach can make regular follow-up simpler for patients and clinicians

Regular follow-up can produce extra demands on clinicians’ and patients’ time, as well as present an extra cost to patients. Options which can help maintain contact with a lower cost to the patient include arranging follow-up appointments with a practice nurse, providing advice in a telephone conversation or via text message. These strategies have all been used with some success in clinical trials of diabetes or weight loss management.30, 31

Encourage people to make use of community groups or peer support

Engaging with a community organisation such as Diabetes New Zealand or a Māori health provider can help patients connect with others with type 2 diabetes and facilitate peer support. Group-based and peer support sessions allow patients to share management strategies, and if health providers are involved, they can discuss barriers with multiple people at once. Practices could consider running their own support groups or holding joint sessions with other practices. Find out about support groups in your area, e.g. run by community or church groups or other organisations.

Patient information about type 2 diabetes:

Information and support on living with type 2 diabetes:

Handouts on weight loss diets and physical activity:

Patient information sheets on the use of metformin:

Information on bariatric surgery:


Using language which can help avoid blame when discussing diabetes. Adapted from the American Association of Diabetes Educators and American Diabetes Association.29

Acknowledgement

Thank you to Professor Tim Cundy, Endocrinologist and Diabetes Specialist, Auckland DHB and School of Medicine, University of Auckland and Dr Paul Drury, Clinical Advisor: Diabetes, Ministry of Health, for expert review of this article.

N.B. Expert reviewers are not responsible for the final content of the article.


Published: 18 May 2018 | Updated:

There are currently no comments for this article.

Please login to make a comment.

Made with by the bpacnz team